Your Expertise is Killing your Marketing

Your Expertise Is Killing Your Marketing

I once worked with a roof installer who wanted to talk about materials, installation techniques, and product specifications. But potential customers wanted to stop leaks and shut out heat. I know, I was one of those people. 

That gap between what you know and what your clients actually need is where most Australian service businesses lose their marketing edge.

The Hidden Desires Problem

Over the 20 years writing or editing for small businesses, I’ve noticed a fundamental shift. Service providers now realise they need to understand their clients’ hidden desires, obstructions and goals. Many want copy written in consumer language, not industry jargon.

The roofer was stuck in his expertise. He thought about materials because that’s his world. But homeowners lie awake worrying about water damage. They don’t care about your technical knowledge until you’ve addressed their actual problem.

This matters also in the business world, because 90% of B2B decision-makers will be Gen X and younger by 2026. They expect business brands to understand them, not lecture them.

The AI Shortcut Trap

Most small business owners aren’t writers. They recognise their marketing needs to be more meaningful, so they reach for ChatGPT. The mistake is when they use Chat-generated copy without thinking through their business values, approach and style first.

Research shows that communications perceived as AI-generated result in moral disgust and reduced customer loyalty. People can sense when there’s no human thinking behind the words.

Before any writing happens, I interview clients with specific questions. Why do you do what you do? How is your approach different? What matters in your industry versus what matters in your actual work? These answers reveal genuine business values, not the generic “integrity, excellence, innovation” words on a website.

A genuine value shows up as education. You’re teaching clients about your service in a way that improves their life or business, not just selling them something.

Australia’s Reputation Economy

Global marketing templates don’t really work here because Australia operates differently.

Our company lists are smaller. Every city is known to most citizens. If a digital marketer advertises heavily but doesn’t deliver, people soon know about it.

Referrals carry enormous weight in this tighter market.

That’s why I don’t promise things that cannot be delivered. And why I ask clients about their referral partners, then call them out on websites or social posts.

Australian B2B buyers engage with 83% of their purchasing journey independently, researching and consuming content before they ever contact you. Your marketing needs to educate and build trust long before the first conversation.

The LinkedIn Community Approach

Small business owners think they need complicated applications like Sales Navigator or auto-posting tools to get traction on LinkedIn.

They’re wrong.

A community approach works better. Offer genuine insights, share business updates and team changes. Engage authentically with your network, giving comments that help them and show your personality.

The real problem is consistency. Business owners post sporadically on LinkedIn or YouTube, then wonder why they get no reach.

LinkedIn accounts for over 80% of all B2B social media leads.

Social sellers are 51% more likely to achieve their quotas than those who don’t build consistent presence.

Take it from peer Gunnar Habitz, this isn’t about posting daily motivational blurbs. It’s about showing up regularly with substance that demonstrates your thinking and values. It’s even, in his case, posting other people’s vignettes and your coffee meeting photograph.

The 2026 Client Replacement Crisis

clients in conversation
Image by Drazen Zigic on Freepik

Small Australian service businesses will struggle most in 2026 if they don’t adapt now. Why?

They’ll struggle to replace clients who leave because they don’t know how to communicate their distinctive value to new people. And, many refuse to share their ‘secrets’, which usually aren’t secrets anyway. They’re insights that would actually build trust and demonstrate expertise.

The businesses that thrive will integrate three marketing approaches that most keep separate:

  1. Social media presence for community building,
  2. Consumer-focused messaging that addresses actual needs, and
  3. Brand-oriented values that attract aligned clients.

Most business owners let their own opinions and consumer habits get in the way. That’s why research on actual consumer and client opinions matters more than our assumptions.

The Partnership Solution

You’re brilliant at your service. That’s not the problem.

The problem is translating that expertise into language that resonates with people who don’t share your technical knowledge but desperately need your help.

Working with a specialist writing contractor isn’t about hiring another voice. It’s about having someone interview you properly, extract your genuine values and approach, then craft messaging that sounds like you at your clearest.

Plain English means respecting your audience enough to make complex ideas accessible. This is also done through careful copyediting.

After 10 years writing for accountants, consultants and manufacturers, I’ve learned that the best marketing doesn’t showcase your expertise. It demonstrates how that expertise solves real problems for real people.

The roofer eventually understood this. His messaging shifted from materials to outcomes.

Your marketing can make the same shift. The question is whether you’ll do it before your competitors do.

If you’re ready to discover how your distinctive value translates into compelling content, let’s have a conversation. Book a free video call and we’ll map out a content strategy that actually works for your business.

We value your opinion, please leave your comment

Scroll to Top